2025 EFMD Case Competition Winners Interviews: Short cases

Short Cases: Real Decisions, Deep Learning

The EFMD Case Writing Competition celebrates outstanding case writing and teaching since 1988. Over the years, it has brought together educators from around the world who are committed to making management education more relevant, rigorous, and impactful.

We continue our 2025 interview series by speaking with the authors behind the winning cases to learn more about their work, their motivation, and the stories behind their submissions.

We are pleased to feature Deval Kartik, HEC Paris Doha, and Siddharth Wadehra, Indian Institute of Management, Ranchi, winners in the “Short Cases: Real Decision, Deep Learning” category.

The category “Short Cases: Real Decision, Deep Learning” is kindly sponsored by Ivey Publishing. EFMD is grateful for their continued commitment to advancing case-based learning and supporting the Case Writing Competition.

‘From Tiktok to Turbulence – Fix Chocolate’s Viral Surge at Strategic Crossroads’ 

1. Could you briefly introduce yourself and provide an overview of the case you have written?

Hello, I am Deval Kartik, Senior Case Writer at HEC Paris. Prior to my career as a full-time case writer, I was an academic, teaching courses in Product & Brand Management, Consumer Behaviour, and marketing.

The Co-author Siddharth Wadehra is a doctoral candidate at the Indian Institute of Management, Ranchi and has worked as a Case Writer with several institutes, such as INSEAD, HBKU in Qatar, AIM in the Philippines, among others.

I have been living and working in the UAE since 2013. When I saw ‘Dubai Chocolate’ boards at the souqs and supermarkets, I was intrigued and dug deeper into what the viral phenomenon was all about. When I learned that the original ‘Fix – Can’t get knafeh of it’ didn’t call itself a ‘Dubai Chocolate’, I could see the case study right in front of me. As the year passed, the virality didn’t fade but only escalated, with more than 200 versions of Dubai Chocolate from brands around the world, pistachio-kunafeh desserts, and a worldwide shortage of pistachio. There were many management lessons in a chocolate bar.

2. Every case is built around a central tension that resists easy resolution. What is the tension at the heart of your case, and why does it matter?

Every big and small brand dreams of going viral, an overnight success. But when that happens, is the founder ready for scaling to meet the demand? When the virality leads to hundreds of brands selling ‘Dubai Chocolate’, how do you affirm your positioning as the original one? How do you protect your artisanal identity while scaling to meet global demand? How do you stay relevant, knowing that someday, the virality will fade?

3. What did writing this case reveal to you that you did not expect to find, and how has it influenced the way you think about your field?

I had observed viral trends rise and fall in a matter of hours, like fireflies. And that is why I waited to see what would happen to Dubai Chocolate. The more I saw it everywhere, in duty-free shops and supermarkets around the world, I realised that small, artisanal brands, with a deep cultural understanding, have the power to challenge the legacy brands. I found Douglas Holt’s “Iconic Brand’ and ‘Cultural Branding ” frameworks very useful to understand this.

4. What broader themes or concepts in management does your case illuminate, and why are they important for students to engage with today?

In the teaching notes accompanying the case study, we have two different versions for two different classes which the case can potentially cater to. The case promotes discussions around competitive strategy, brand management, growth and scaling strategies, organisational transformation, and entrepreneurship. Additionally, the case also invites discussion on product differentiation, classical branding vs hit marketing, cultural branding, and brand positioning.

5. If your case continues to be taught a decade from now, what do you believe it will say about the period in which it was written?

“This was a time when a small artisanal chocolate brand went viral and took the world by such a storm that all legacy brands and hundreds of others copied it, creating a worldwide shortage of pistachio.”

It will also show how social media virality is transient, and brands need to be stronger than a ‘hit marketing’ phenomenon. By 2026, many European countries will have established geographic markings, and only products made in the specific region can use that name. Just like sparkling wine made elsewhere can’t be called Champagne, unless the chocolate is made in Dubai, it can’t be called ‘Dubai Chocolate’. Now, most chocolates with these ingredients call themselves ‘pistachio-kunafeh’ chocolates. What happens to the ‘Original Dubai Chocolate’ positioning of Fix?


The Sponsor’s Commentary

The category “Short Cases: Real Decision, Deep Learning” is kindly sponsored by Ivey Publishing. EFMD deeply appreciates the invaluable expertise and the dedicated efforts of Ivey Publishing in supporting the Case Writing Competition.

1. Could you share a brief overview of your institution?

At Ivey Publishing, we equip business educators with the resources to shape future leaders through case-based learning. We do this by collaborating with a global community of authors, educators, and institutions to develop high-quality learning materials that bring real-world challenges into the classroom.

Our catalogue features more than 50,000 learning materials, including more than 10,000 in our Ivey collection. We are also proud to add approximately 500 classroom-tested case studies and other learning materials each year. Clear, concise, and current, our publications are recognised by the academic community for meeting the rigorous demands of management education and responding to ever-changing challenges in business and society overall.

Our commitment to championing case learning for the world is what drives us to support initiatives that advance case pedagogy, including the EFMD Global Case Writing Competition and our own case competitions developed in collaboration with partner organisations.

2. What qualities distinguish a truly great teaching case from a merely good one, in your view?

Great case learning begins with great case authors, and we believe case authors deserve the same recognition extended to researchers publishing in top-tier journals. Sponsoring the EFMD Global Case Writing Competition is one of the most direct ways we can signal that case writing is a rigorous and valuable form of scholarship, worthy of celebration on a global stage.

The Short Cases: Real Decisions, Deep Learning category is particularly meaningful to us because it reflects how Ivey has always thought about case design. We have long recognised that brevity, when paired with rigour, produces the most engaging classroom experiences.

It is important to draw a clear distinction. The market has seen a wave of short-form, “quick-read” cases designed primarily for speed. Brief vignettes students can skim and discuss in passing. That is not what this category is about. A great short case is concise, not simplified. It is distilled, but not lightweight. It is peer-reviewed, theoretically grounded, paired with a robust teaching note, and designed to sustain a full 60- or 90-minute discussion, just like longer-format cases.

This category also arrives at the right moment. Faculty are teaching in compressed, modular, and hybrid formats, and generative AI has changed how students prepare. What we mean by this is that long cases are increasingly read through an AI summary rather than cover to cover. A well-crafted short case helps solve that problem because students can read it in class and spend the session doing what AI cannot do for them, which is debating, deciding, and defending their reasoning in front of their peers.

3. Why is sponsoring a case writing competition a meaningful way for your institution to contribute to management education?

Whether three pages or thirty, a great case puts the student right in the protagonist’s chair and refuses to let them out until they have made a decision they can defend.

The best cases we publish tend to share a few defining qualities. They present a decision that genuinely divides the room. If a thoughtful student can arrive at the “right” answer within minutes, the case is probably doing too much of the work. The strongest cases keep the discussion going because the tensions at the heart of the decision are real, complicated, and don’t have an easy answer.

They also feature protagonists that students can truly relate to. This means people whose challenges, goals, and blind spots feel real enough that students can put themselves in their shoes and wrestle with the same difficult choices. Great cases are distilled rather than simplified. Every detail has a purpose, bringing out the complexity of the situation without overwhelming the student.

The strongest cases also have the ability to open up different conversations. A single case might support a strategy discussion one day and an ethics discussion the next, allowing students to look at the same decision from different angles. But even the strongest case is elevated by a thoughtful teaching note that helps instructors bring the discussion to life, anticipate where students might go, and connect important concepts to the decision at hand.

We’re living in an era when students can generate a decent case analysis in seconds. That only makes the live, unscripted classroom conversation more valuable. The cases that really stand out are the ones built to spark that conversation.

4. What does the winning case in your category reveal about the kind of thinking business schools should be cultivating in their students?

From TikTok to Turbulence: Fix Chocolate’s Viral Surge at a Strategic Crossroads is exactly the kind of case we hoped this category would attract. In just a few pages, the authors place students in the middle of a timely, fast-moving challenge: a viral consumer brand suddenly facing the operational, strategic, and reputation challenges that come with a level of demand it never expected.

There is no obvious right answer, and that is what makes the case so compelling. Students cannot simply apply a framework from a textbook and move on. They must balance growth with capacity, short-term opportunities with long-term goals, and the excitement of a viral moment with the challenge of building a lasting brand. They have to make decisions with incomplete information, knowing the market may have already changed by the time they present their recommendation. That is the reality business leaders face every day.

This is exactly the kind of thinking business schools should be developing: curiosity, critical thinking, adaptability, and sound judgment. These are also the skills that remain difficult for AI to replicate. A language model can summarise Fix Chocolate’s situation, but it cannot sit in a classroom, defend a recommendation, respond to a challenging question from a classmate, and rethink its position in the moment.

Our congratulations once again to Deval Kartik and Siddharth Wadehra for creating exactly the kind of short case this category was designed to celebrate.


About Sponsorship

EFMD Case Writing Competition is proud to have dedicated sponsors who drive management education towards impactful teaching and learning. Sponsoring a category allows you to showcase your institution’s expertise in the specific field of management education in the wide EFMD network. The choice of category, its exact definition and any specific conditions are the privileges of the sponsor. Sponsorships for the following categories are currently available: Continuous Improvement: the Journey to Excellence, and Finance and Banking. To find out more, please contact Petra Grestenbergerova at petra.grestenbergerova@efmdglobal.org.

More information about the 2025 EFMD Case Writing Competition winners can be found at the EFMD Case Writing Competition page. Please visit The Case Centre’s webpage to access the collection of the winning cases. See other interviews from this series.

You may also like: